Is a hot dog a sandwich?

[eaty]

As the title stated, do you consider a hot dog (complete with roll) a sandwich?

The definition of sandwich is:

an item of food consisting of two pieces of bread with meat, cheese, or other filling between them, eaten as a light meal.

So by that definition it could be considered a sandwich. But I don't think it really is. What do you think?

[Dawn.]

I would consider a hot dog as a sandwich.

[Astro04]

I don't consider it a "sandwich". Guess the way you put the food into the bread makes the difference.

[Silvan]

A hot dog is a hot dog and a sandwich is a sandwich! :P Hot dogs are usually served in special buns with sausages and sauces inside, while sandwiches can be made using different types of buns/bread, different ingredients put on top etc.

[Ethereal.]

A hot dog is as much of a sandwich as a burger is.

In other words: No, a hot dog is not a sandwich.

[Everglow.]

Originally Posted by Matter

A hot dog is a hot dog and a sandwich is a sandwich!

Exactly this!

[Wheek!]

But a burger can be a sandwich

[Ethereal.]

Originally Posted by Wheek!

But a burger can be a sandwich

In what way?

[Wingless.]

My vote is also no. In my mind a sandwich has filling between two slices of bread, so a hot dog doesn't count because it's on a bun.

[Wheek!]

I’ve eaten hot dogs on bread before and not a bun Is it only a sandwich sometimes?

[Wingless.]

Originally Posted by Wheek!

I’ve eaten hot dogs on bread before and not a bun Is it only a sandwich sometimes?

That would be a sandwich but not technically a hot dog then.

[Wheek!]

Originally Posted by Wingless.

That would be a sandwich but not technically a hot dog then.

Also what if I had half a sandwich? I sometimes make peanut butter sandwiches on one piece of bread and fold it in half! Not two pieces!

[Wingless.]

Originally Posted by Wheek!

Also what if I had half a sandwich? I sometimes make peanut butter sandwiches on one piece of bread and fold it in half! Not two pieces!

That's not a sandwich either, that's just a fancy slice of bread.

[MsNobleEleanor]

I did other. I think it's just one of those things where it's just simply a hot dog on a bun. I have used a piece of bread and put the hot dog on there and folded it, I have also used hot dog buns. They don't call them, "hot dog sandwiches" in the store when buy the bread it's called a "bun".

I think it's just it's own category.

I have put cheese on mine because it tastes so much better that way. I also don't eat hot dogs often anyways.

What do you call the bun of the hot dog then? It's not a sandwich, is it? It's just the bun itself. Just like a hamburger bun; is that a sandwich? We just don't call it a sandwich...

[Wheek!]

Two other people voted yes. I’m so less alone now.

[Rika]

There's even an article on this I enjoyed reading!

https://www.hot-dog.org/culture/hot-dog-sandwich

and

http://www.hot-dog.org/press/nationa...ch-controversy

I personally do consider it a sandwich myself! You use a hot dog bun which is two pieces of bread.